Topic on Project:Village Pump

Tracked in Phabricator
Task T234246

Hi all
From page => https://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/API:Fileinfo from last link https://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/Special:MyLanguage/API/Architecture_work/Planning#Rewrite_prop=imageinfo_from_scratch_as_prop=fileinfo I want to skip to the section 3.5 Rewrite prop=imageinfo... but when I click on it, I jump a few lines before section 3.6.1 Comments (Clean up...
What is the problem ? (...the = ?) and what is the correct syntax to access the requested section 3.5 (Im under Firefox). Thanks.

It seems to acces the right section and then suddenly shifts down a few lines.

Christian FR (talk) 09:10, 29 September 2019 (UTC)

It is caused by "These comments refer to a previous version of this proposal" box at API/Architecture_work/Planning#Comments_(Changes_to_JSON_output_format).

At first, the box is expanded, but it will automatically be collapsed after the completion of loading document, so the scroll position will change.

So what do we conclude ? Is there an attached task in Phabricator ? If no I will create one, but what is your reference source to say that ? Can you please explain more. Thanks.

Please add a reference to phab:T219193 which is where the addition of the tabs was proposed.

Where ? this task is closed in Phabicator and there is still a misalignment when I call the anchor. So where do we signall that ?

More of that, the developper replies "I have checked both pages API/Architecture work/Planning and API:Fileinfo. Both do not use div.mw-gadget-tabbedwindow element. That means it is totally unrelated to our tab windows gadget."

Sorry, I though it was the same as the API pages where they have the tabs...

After some investigations I can say that Shirayuki is right. My conclusions are the followingː

• If I define anchor #jsonoutput BEFORE the hidden box, the anchor https://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/API/Architecture_work/Planning#jsonoutput is well accessed.
• If I comment the hidden box (&oldid=3437306), the anchor https://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/API/Architecture_work/Planning#Rewrite_prop=imageinfo_from_scratch_as_prop=fileinfo of this topic is well accessedi

So the problem is linked with hidden template.

Surprise: it works on a Samsung Tablet: what is the difference  :

On the tablet (version mobile), when the called page is displayed, the box of 'hidden' declaration is shown open and the anchor is then functional.

A contrario, on my laptop (anonymous connexion, or skin Vector) when the called page is displayed, the box of 'hidden' declaration is shown closed and the anchor is misaligned.

Who is responsible ?

What browser are you using when it fails? I've tested with Firefox and works well, no misalignment.

... informations continue in referenced Phabricator task; please document pro/contra subject with the concrete informations.

I am investigating around impact.