Watch Analytics provides two numbers:
Reviews is clearly the number of reviews limited by the number of reviewers,
My users are asking me how Scrutiny is calculated. Is this stated somewhere in the documentation and I have missed it? or is this something you can explain a little better here? Thanks!
It's calculated based upon how many watchers and how "good" at watching those watchers are. IIRC, how good they are is based entirely upon how big/old their list of pending reviews is. Ideally it'd take into account historically how good they've been, and perhaps other factors like how many thanks they've gotten, what groups they're in, etc. A highly active sysop being more effective at watching a page than an inactive newbie...so the sysop gives more to the scrutiny score.
I understand your answer, but, assuming a page has a scrutiny value of "X", the basic question I keep getting is, "X on a scale of what? X out of 5? X our of 100?". My audience is a lot of engineers :-P
what is the highest value of scrutiny possible by the extension? or is it's max value a function of the total number of users?
