Hackathons/Wikimania 2017 Lessons Learned
This page is a combination of feedback from a survey sent to participants and ideas from the organizers.
For more information about the event please see: https://wikimania2017.wikimedia.org/wiki/Hackathon
The Best
[edit]The Worst
[edit]Suggested Changes for next time
[edit]Background on Feedback Survey
[edit]- This feedback about the Wikimania Hackathon 2017 was a section in the main Wikimania feedback survey which was shown only to respondents who indicated that they had attended the hackathon.
- The survey was first sent out on <ADD DATE>
- 52 people responded to the Hackathon Feedback Survey
Qualitative Feedback
[edit]This feedback is based on fill in the blank comments, grouped into similar themes, interoperated by rfarrand and listed in order of most-commented
Mentoring Program and Newcomers
[edit]What worked well with the mentoring program?
[edit]- Good mentors
- Visible
- Matching interests
- Results achieved
- Met people
- Got help
- Learned
- Telegram worked
- Posters worked
What should be improved about the mentoring program?
[edit]- Not enough mentees / not enough mentees in my area
- More projects
- Whiteboards instead of paper
- Where to go for different programming language help
- Helpdesk and mentoring area should be close
- After poster session newcomers had time finding mentors
Questions for Newcomers
[edit]How did you experience the amount of new information you got? (e.g. I wanted more, I felt overwhelmed, I followed along well)
[edit]- I followed along well / it was the right amount / good: 15 people
- Wanted more information: 2 people
- Wanted less information: 2 people
- Didn't get much new info: 1 person
How did you experience the social atmosphere?
[edit]- It was good / something positive: 18 people
- Mentions the friendly atmosphere: 4 people
- Hard to meet people: 3 people
After attending the hackathon, would you feel prepared enough to keep working on MediaWiki projects?
[edit]- Yes: 17 people
- I am already paid to do this: 2 people
- Not yet: 2 people
- Not specifically on mediawiki: 1 person
- probably: 1 person
What did you find most confusing about the existing Wikimedia technical documentation?
[edit]Which Wikimedia technical documentation pages were the most useful for you?
[edit]What Wikimedia technical documentation did you want to find, but couldn't find?
[edit]What was the most interesting conversation which you had with other community members?
[edit]Programs and Collaboration
Opening / Closing Sessions
Sessions/Schedule
Accomplishments
Anything else?
Quantitate Feedback
[edit]This is data straight from the feedback survey
How would you describe your experience as a developer?
[edit](Choose the option that best describes your experience level)
52 responses
- I am not a developer: 17.3%
- Beginner (just starting out): 9.6%
- Intermediate (less than 5 years) 21.2%
- Advanced (more than 5 years or have a high level of knowledge in my area): 51.9%
Including this event, how many Wikimedia or Wikimania hackathons have you attended?
[edit]52 responses
- 1: 13.5%
- 2: 13.5%
- 3: 17.3%
- 4:7.7%
- 5: 5.8%
- 6 or more: 42.3%
How would you describe your overall experience at the Hackathon?
[edit]52 responses
- Very Positive: 48.1%
- Positive: 50%
- Neither Negative nor Positive: 1.9%
- Negative: 0%
- Very Negative: 0%
Mentoring Program and Newcomers
[edit]Did you participate in the mentoring and newcomers program
[edit]52 responses
- Yes, as a newcomer: 9.6%
- Yes, a mentor: 19.2%
- I helped in another way: 11.5%
- No: 59.6%
If you participated please rate your overall experience with the mentoring program
[edit]21 responses
- Very Positive: 19%
- Positive: 38.1%
- Neither Negative nor Positive: 42.9%
- Negative: 0%
- Very Negative: 0%
Questions for Newcomers
[edit]Did you also attend the main Wikimania Conference?
[edit]39 responses
- Yes: 100%
- No: 0%
How useful did you find the sessions for newcomers?
[edit]27 responses
- Completely Useful: 3.7%
- Mostly Useful: 14.8%
- Moderately Useful: 7.4%
- Somewhat Useful: 0%
- Not at all Useful: 0%
- Did not attend: 74.1%
Programs and Collaboration
[edit]How useful did you find the skill share board?
[edit]50 responses
- Completely Useful: 2%
- Mostly Useful: 18%
- Moderately Useful: 14%
- Somewhat Useful: 4%
- Not at all Useful: 2%
- Did not use: 60%
How was it to find people to work with?
[edit]48 responses
- Very Easy: 18.8%
- Easy: 41.7%
- Neither Easy nor Difficult: 33.3%
- Difficult: 6.3%
- Very Difficult: 0%
Did you participate in the volunteering program?
[edit]21 responses
- Event Photography: 5 people
- Event Blogging: 2 people
- Host: 0 people
- Mid-event Phabricator and Wiki-updates: 4 people
- Help Desk: 9 people
- Others mentioned in fill-in-the-blank: workshop with skillshare, telegram, session, search and discovery table.
Opening / Closing Sessions
[edit]How useful were each of the following sessions?
Hackathon Opening Session
[edit]- Not at all: 0
- Somewhat: 4 people
- Moderately: 2 people
- Mostly: 21 people
- Completely: 16 people
- Did not attend: 7 people
Hackathon Showcase Session
[edit]- Not at all: 0
- Somewhat: 1 person
- Moderately: 2 people
- Mostly: 13 people
- Completely: 17 people
- Did not attend: 18 people
Sessions/Schedule
[edit]How satisfied were you with the selection of breakout sessions?
[edit]42 responses
- 1 (not satisfied): 0%
- 2: 0%
- 3: 21.4%
- 4: 61.9%
- 5: 16.7%
Accomplishments
[edit]51 responses (people could answer more than one response)
- Improved a Community Wishlist task: 6
- Wrote code for a new tool or project: 14
- Added features to an existing tool: 20
- Fixed bugs: 24
- Created templates: 2
- Answered research questions: 9
- Worked on research / analytics: 7
- Agreed on a solution to an old problem: 21
- Discussed future plans in a formal meeting: 17
- 16 other responses in fill-in-the-blank
Anything else?
[edit]Attending this event was worth my time
[edit]- Strongly agree: 34 people
- Agree: 15 people
- Neither Agree or disagree: 2 people
- Disagree: 0 people
- Strongly disagree: 1 person
The opportunity to meet fellow developers and Wikimedians was valuable to me
[edit]- Strongly agree: 46 people
- Agree: 5 people
- Neither Agree or disagree: 1 person
- disagree: 0
- Strongly disagree: 0
I would like to attend this event again next year.
[edit]- Strongly agree: 36
- Agree: 15
- Neither Agree or disagree: 0
- disagree: 0
- Strongly disagree: 0