Article feedback/Version 5/Test Plan

AFT v5 test plan

Sanity tests

SAN-001: Feedback form rendering (anonymous user)

Purposes:

1. Verify correct rendering of the article and appearance of a feedback interface form
2. Verify consistency of the bucketing mechanism for anonymous users

	Step	Expected result
1	Log out from mediawiki (if logged in)	Login/profile toolbar on top reflects the user is not logged in
2	Open a wiki page	The page renders correctly A feedback interface (any of them) is rendered below the article
3	Open another wikipedia article	The interface option rendered is the same as in step 2

SAN-002: Feedback form rendering (logged in user)

Purpose: verify consistency of the bucketing mechanism for logged in users Prerequisite: clear mediawiki cookies after execution of previous tests

	Step	Expected result
1	Log in to mediawiki	Login/profile toolbar on top reflects your login
2	Open a wiki page	The page renders correctly A feedback interface (any of them) is rendered below the article
3	Open another wikipedia article	The interface option rendered is the same as in step 2

Compatibility/conflicts tests

The purpose of these tests is to ensure no conflicts exist between the AFTv5 and other MediaWiki functionality, including AFTv4.

Feedback option 1 tests

The purpose of these tests is to verify correct functionality of feedback interface option 1 (yes/no + comment)

FB1-001: UI and functional test (full feedback)

	Step	Expected result
1	Log in to mediawiki	Login/profile toolbar on top reflects your login
2	Open a wiki page with URL GET parameter bucket=1	Feedback interface option 1 is rendered at the bottom of the page Submit button is disabled Yes/No buttons: neither is checked Comment box is empty
3	Hover the mouse over the yes/no buttons	Button hover state is visualized
4	Select the "Yes" button	"Yes" button's checked state is visualized The comment box shows a grayed-out placeholder text, as defined for the "Yes" button The submit button is enabled
5	Select the "No" button	"No" buttons checked state is visualized "Yes" button is unchecked, and its unchecked state is visualized The comment box shows a grayed-out placeholder text, different than the "Yes" button's text The submit button is enabled
6	Fill in a comment text	Text is visible in the comment box Yes/No button state remains as it was Submit button is enabled
7	Click on the Submit button	Feedback is submitted without page refresh The relevant CTA is displayed

FB1-002: UI and functional test (partial feedback)

	Step	Expected result
1	Repeat steps 1, 2 from FB1-001	Same as FB1-001
2	Select the "Yes" button	"Yes" button's checked state is visualized The comment box shows a grayed-out placeholder text, as defined for the "Yes" button The submit button is enabled
3	Click on the Submit button	Feedback is submitted without page refresh The relevant CTA is displayed

Feedback option 2 tests

The purpose of these tests is to verify correct functionality of feedback interface option 2 (yes/no + comment)

FB2-001: UI and functional test (full feedback)

	Step	Expected result
1	Log in to mediawiki	Login/profile toolbar on top reflects your login
2	Open a wiki page with URL GET parameter bucket=2	Feedback interface option 2 is rendered at the bottom of the page Submit button is enabled First tab is selected by default Comment displays a grayed-out placeholder text relevant for tab 1 (selected tab)
3	Hover the mouse over the non-selected tabs	Tabs' hover state is visualized
4	Select the second tab	The second tab's checked state is visualized The comment box shows a grayed-out placeholder text relevant for the selected tab The submit button is enabled
5	Repeat step 4 for the third and fourth tabs	The selected tab's checked state is visualized The comment box shows a grayed-out placeholder text relevant for the selected tab The submit button is enabled
6	Fill in a comment text	Text is visible in the comment box Tab selection remains as it was Submit button is enabled
7	Click on the Submit button	Feedback is submitted without page refresh The relevant CTA is displayed

FB2-002: UI and functional test (partial feedback)

	Step	Expected result
1	Repeat steps 1, 2 from FB1-001	Same as FB1-001
2	Select the second tab	The second tab's checked state is visualized The comment box shows a grayed-out placeholder text relevant for the selected tab The submit button is enabled
3	Click on the Submit button	Feedback is submitted without page refresh The relevant CTA is displayed